c/bbq-pitmasters

Found out my grandpa's old smoker was a $40 hardware store special

Went through my old man's garage last month and dug out his 1980s offset smoker. I assumed it was some fancy pit from back in the day, but the rusted badge says it came from a True Value in Tulsa for $40. That thing turned out some of the best brisket I ever ate, and I've dropped $600 on rigs that can't touch it. Makes you wonder if the gear matters or if it's all in how you tend the fire, you know? Anyone else find a beat-up hand-me-down that outperformed their expensive stuff?

0 comments

harperp31•11d ago

A brisket class in Lockhart flipped my whole trimming game

Honestly I drove 3 hours to Lockhart last month for a Saturday class at one of those old pit spots. The instructor pointed out I was slicing off too much fat cap, like over 70% of it, before the smoke even started. He said to leave a quarter inch and let the render do the work, and the bark came out way better on my last two cooks. Anyone else pick up a trick from a pitmaster that made you rethink a basic step?

1 comments

sarah_brown•12d ago

Hit 500 briskets on my offset last weekend

Smoked my 500th brisket last Sunday on the old Oklahoma Joe in Austin. Numbers tracked on a dry erase board in the shed. That 500th one came out damn near perfect, better than the first 50 combined. Anyone else keep count of their cooks or am I the only weirdo with a tally system?

1 comments

jakef66•13d ago

The $12 water pan trick that fixed my brisket bark in one cook

Ran a brisket last Saturday on my offset and the bark kept coming out soft and dark, almost like a stew coating. I blamed my wood splits or my fire management for months. Then my buddy who competes in a KCBS circuit in Kansas City told me he lines his water pan with foil and adds boiling water every hour, no exceptions. I tried it, kept the pan full the whole cook, and the bark set up like a shell. I think my firebox was pulling too much moisture out of the chamber and the pan was just sitting there empty, doing nothing. The difference was night and day. Has anyone else messed with water pan levels mid-cook or do you just fill it once and forget it?

1 comments

ward.fiona•19d ago

The $12 pork butt from Walmart turned out better than the $45 heritage one

I laughed at my buddy when he grabbed that cheap shoulder for our Sunday smoke, figured it'd be dry trash. Marinated it overnight in apple juice and mustard, 11 hours on the offset at 225, and it pulled apart like butter while the expensive one stayed tough. Has anyone else had the cheap cut just show up the fancy stuff?

1 comments

fox.skyler•20d ago

That food truck in Austin with the 14 hour brisket

Stopped by a trailer off Lamar last weekend, guy runs a solo operation with two offsets. He said he wraps at 165 with butcher paper and pulls at 203, then rests in a cooler for 3 hours. Best bark I've had outside of Franklin's, but he only does about 40 pounds a day and sells out by 2 PM. Anyone else found a small spot that beats the big names when you catch them on the right day?

1 comments

nancy391•22d ago

Hit my 500th brisket last weekend and somehow it was the worst one yet

Got the counter to 500 briskets over 11 years of backyard and competition cooking. Figured I'd do something special, maybe invite the neighbors over, show off a bit. That thing came out dry as a popcorn fart. Bark was fine, smoke ring was there, but the flat crumbled like sawdust. My wife just looked at me and said it's good with sauce. I don't know if I got complacent or the meat was just tough luck, but it kind of humbles you. Anyone else hit a milestone and totally bombed it right at the number? How do you shake that off before the next cook?

1 comments

blairm35•22d ago

That $40 probe thermometer from the gas station was dead accurate, I'm embarrassed

I laughed at my buddy when he pulled it out at his place in Austin, but we checked it against my ThermoPop on three different briskets and it never missed by more than 1 degree, so has anyone else had a cheapo gadget surprise them like this?

1 comments

faithf77•22d ago

Wood chunks vs pellets for my offset, trial lasted 3 weekends

I ran my Oklahoma Joe offset for three Saturdays straight with mesquite chunks first, then switched to pellets and the temp swings were way worse with pellets, like 40 degrees either way. The bark on my brisket was also thinner and less crunchy with the pellets, even though I kept the same fire management routine. Has anyone else found that chunks give you a steadier burn in a cheaper offset, or am I just bad at feeding pellets?

1 comments

carr.xena•24d ago

My worst barbecue weekend ever, three ruined briskets in 48 hours

Last August I did a backyard comp for my street and every single brisket came out like shoe leather, even the one I wrapped at 165 exactly. I think the issue was my smoker's temp swings from that cheap gasket kit, but I'm not sure. Has anyone else had a whole weekend fall apart and figure out it was one tiny fix?

1 comments

ruby_foster93•25d ago

Watched a buddy ruin his offset smoker last weekend and I still can't believe it

My friend Dave from down the street got this nice 120 gallon offset smoker about 3 years ago. He always bragged about how he knew everything about BBQ cause he watched some YouTube videos. Well last Saturday we had a big cookout planned and he asked me to come help fire it up. He poured a whole 5 gallon bucket of charcoal in there and doused it with lighter fluid. Then he hit it with a propane torch and let the fire get out of control for like 20 minutes before he even put any wood on. The whole chamber shot up to 500 degrees and warped the firebox door so bad it won't close now. He was all red faced and swearing at me like it was my fault. Has anyone else seen someone mess up a good smoker by not learning fire management first?

2 comments

emmag40•28d ago

I finally learned why my brisket was drying out from a guy in Lockhart

I was at Blacks BBQ in Lockhart last Saturday and got to chatting with this pitmaster who's been there 18 years. He told me I was wrapping my brisket way too early in the stall, around 150 degrees instead of waiting until 165 or so. I tried his method on a 14 pound prime packer last night and the flat came out juicy for the first time in months. Has anyone else had better luck wrapping later?

1 comments

kelly.keith•29d ago

Had to pick between a $200 offset smoker and a $400 Weber kettle for my backyard

I went with the Weber kettle because I figured I could learn temp control on it easier, and after 6 months of brisket and ribs, I think I made the right call for now but has anyone else regretted going cheaper on their first rig?

1 comments

ninah10•1mo ago

Dropped $200 on a smoker mod that did nothing

Bought a fancy tuning plate for my offset thinking it would fix hot spots. All it did was rust up in two cooks, any of you guys find a cheap fix that actually works?

2 comments

phoenixb66•1mo ago

The old pitmaster at a roadside joint in Alabama showed me something I never forgot

He grabbed a handful of hickory chunks, tossed them in the firebox, and said "son, smoke is seasoning not fuel" without even looking up. Has anyone else gotten advice from an old timer that completely flipped how you approach a cook?

2 comments

kim.charlie•1mo ago

Put a brisket on at midnight and woke up to a stall 10 degrees higher than usual

Ngl, I thought starting a 14 pound packer at midnight would let me sleep through the first few hours. Woke up at 6am to find the internal temp stuck at 175 instead of my usual 165 stall. Cooker was holding steady at 250 so I figured it was the meat itself, maybe higher collagen content or something. Has anyone else hit a weirdly high stall and just rolled with it or did you bump the heat up early?

2 comments

emmajackson•1mo ago

Why does nobody talk about how Franklin BBQ in Austin is overhyped?

I waited 4 hours in line there last month and honestly the brisket was good but not life changing. The bark was a little soft and the fat cap wasn't rendered all the way through. I've had better from a guy running a pit in his backyard in Lockhart. Am I missing something or does the hype just outrun the actual product?

2 comments

kellyg14•1mo ago

I finally caught someone using water instead of apple juice in their mop sauce at a competition in Memphis last Saturday

The guy next to me at the Memphis BBQ Fest was bragging about his mop sauce recipe, then I watched him pour straight tap water into his spray bottle. Why bother competing if you're not even going to try for a proper bark? Has anyone else seen this kind of shortcut out there?

2 comments

felixh45•1mo ago

Watched a guy ruin a brisket by taking it off too early

I was at a competition in Kansas City last fall and this guy pulled his brisket at 190 degrees internal. He said he was running out of time for the turn-in window. I get that deadlines matter but man, that meat was tough as shoe leather when he sliced it. Why do so many people ignore the feel test and just go by a number on their probe?

2 comments

terry1•1mo ago

Spent 3 hours trimming a brisket before I realized I was taking off the wrong fat cap

I kept watching these competition videos where they shave it down to almost nothing. Forgot I was cooking for a family of 6 who like their meat juicy, not dry. Anyone else overthink a trim and ruin a good packer?

2 comments

blake_williams•1mo ago

I hit 100 briskets smoked and most of them were way overrated

Last weekend I pulled my 100th brisket off the smoker. It was a 14 pound prime from Costco in Austin. Everyone online acts like brisket is the holy grail of BBQ, but honestly I think pulled pork is way more forgiving and tastes just as good if not better. Am I the only one who thinks brisket gets too much credit for being hard when it's really just expensive and finicky?

2 comments

abby_carr57•1mo ago

Hot take: Most people ruin their brisket by pulling it too early

I watched a guy at a comp in Kansas City last weekend slice into his brisket at 195 degrees and it was like cutting leather. I keep my probe in until it hits 203 and feels like jiggly butter when I poke it. The stall can fool you into thinking it's done but collagen hasn't fully broken down yet. Anyone else notice how many folks pull theirs at 190-195 and end up with tough meat?

2 comments

leoyoung•1mo ago

A guy at a comp in Kansas City showed me why I was overthinking my rubs

I was at the American Royal last year, just walking through the vendor area, and this old timer with a beat up smoker pulled me aside. He saw me obsessing over a $40 custom rub blend and laughed. Told me to stop chasing fancy ingredients and just focus on salt, pepper, and garlic powder in the right ratio. I spent like 6 months before that trying every trendy rub with coffee and cocoa powder and getting inconsistent results. After listening to him, I switched to his simple mix for my backyard cooks and my pork shoulders came out way better. It really made me realize the pros keep it simple for a reason. Has anyone else had a random encounter at a comp completely change how they cook?

2 comments

rose_henderson•1mo ago

Brisket wrap debate: butcher paper vs foil, what's your call?

I had a brisket on my WSM last weekend for a family gathering. I wrapped it in pink butcher paper around 165 internal temp, but two hours later it was stalling hard at 170. I switched to foil just to save time, and the bark got soft but the cook finished in 3 hours. The meat was tender but the bark wasn't as crispy as I like. How do you decide which wrap to go with, or do you avoid wrapping at all?

2 comments

kai564•1mo ago

Best brisket day I ever had was a total accident

So last Saturday I was running late for a cook at my buddy's place in Austin and grabbed a brisket that had been sitting in my fridge for 3 days dry brined. I forgot to take it out early so I threw it on the smoker cold straight from the fridge at 225. Figured it was gonna be a disaster but I was already behind so I just rolled with it. Ended up that long cold start gave it way more smoke absorption than usual and the bark set up perfect after 6 hours. I wrapped it in butcher paper at 170 and let it go to 203 and it rested for 2 hours in a cooler. When I sliced into it the thing just fell apart and had this deep smoke ring like 1/4 inch thick. Everyone kept asking what I did different and I had to tell them I just messed up my timing. Anyone else ever get a perfect cook from screwing up the prep?

2 comments