Picked the open carrier over enclosed for my Civic from Phoenix to Portland, saved $650
Kept going back and forth on it for a week since the car's not perfect and I was worried about rock chips on the 1,200 mile haul. Went open, and the only damage was one small chip on the hood that I honestly can't even tell was new. For $650 less I'd do it again, but has anyone had a bad run with an open carrier that makes them wish they'd sprung for enclosed?
Small correction, a 1,200 mile haul to Portland is more like 1,300+ depending on the route, ha. Open is fine for most cars though, the rock chip risk is way overblown.